Skip to main content

Utah Property Management Blog

What You Do When You Inherit a Tenant

What You Do When You Inherit a Tenant

When an investor purchases a property with an existing tenant, the first thoughts are that rent will immediately come in and there will be no vacancy period. This means initially avoiding higher maintenance costs, leasing fees, and advertising costs. Of course, everyone hopes this is the ideal tenant and the rental agreement has all the best terms, but in many cases, inheriting the tenant with the property may not necessarily be an advantage. There are different scenarios that can happen. 

Review the Rental Agreement 

The first thing we do is determine what the tenant’s rental agreement contains. Is it a lease or a month-to-month tenancy? If it is a lease, then how long a period before the lease ends? What terms are contained in the agreement? Is the rent too low? Does the rental agreement contain the legal requirements to protect the property owner – for example, does the property require a lead-based paint addendum? Reviewing the lease first will determine if you can raise the rent, remove the tenant, and/or change any necessary terms. 

Reviewing the Tenancy 

Next, we take the time to review the overall tenancy. Could it cost more in the long haul to keep this tenant? Whether the tenant is or is not on a lease, determining the quality of the tenancy is important even if you have to wait to give a notice or change of terms. 

Does the tenant take care of the property? If the answer is no, keeping this tenant is costly to the investment; the property will only deteriorate over time and maintenance costs will be higher. Does the tenant pay on time? Poor payment history often leads to legal problems. This may take a few months to determine if the former owner and/or agent have not given the most accurate picture of the tenant’s rental history. When a tenant does not pay on time after receiving timely notices to quit, they rarely change their spots and will continue to be a payment problem. It is better to move on to a better tenant as soon as possible. Will increasing the rent cause a serious tenant problem or a notice to move? Does the property need renovations require vacating the tenant to do them properly? Trying to do major maintenance while a tenant lives in a property can be more costly and can create other landlord/tenant issues. 

Make a Plan 

Once the status of the tenancy is determined, it is time to create a plan of action. If keeping the tenant is not a favorable decision and there is no long-term lease or the lease is shortly coming due, do not procrastinate – it is time to give the tenant a reasonable notice to vacate. The concern here may be that this will create legal problems. 

If this is a poor tenant, chances are legal problems, property damage, or security deposit dispute will happen anyway. If it has been determined that the lease prevents an immediate notice, then discuss a plan with your manager when to implement this action. It may be that keeping the tenant is the best course of action, but changing any term of the tenancy, particularly rent, can cause a vacancy. If there is going to be a rent increase, be sure that the property maintenance is current, the increase is reasonable, that proper notice is given, and that all lines of communication are open. Most tenants are already afraid of what will happen when a new owner takes over. It is advisable to have the tenant sign a new lease, and this can be awkward if there is to be an increase in rent. Move cautiously if the tenant is worthwhile keeping. 

Remember – if you do buy a property with an existing tenant, the property is an investment, but this is also the tenant’s current home. The tenant is a key factor to how well your investment performs, but if they are not the right tenant for the property or the terms are not right for the investment, it is important to make necessary changes. Discuss your options with us to develop a plan of action to protect your investment. If you have a question about this topic or need assistance with anything else, contact a TierOne Real Estate Property Manager at 801-486-6200.